Shy Girl Baking Co.
Cakes & Treats
Custom Cakes
4" Cake (feeds 2-4) starting at $40
6" Cake (feeds 8-10) starting at $80
8" Cake (feeds 15-20) starting at $100
10" Cake (feeds 30-40) starting at $120
Cupcakes Starting at $30/Dozen
Flavors: custom (write in your request) Best Sellers: vanilla, funfetti, chocolate, citrus, strawberry, banana nut, lemon, pistachio, carrot, red velvet
Seasonal: pumpkin, apple spice
Cake
Flavors: custom (write in your request) Best Sellers: fresh fruit, homemade jam, caramel, praline, buttercream, berries & cream, ganache, lemon curd
Seasonal: pumpkin spice late, salted caramel, spiced apples, pie filling, halloween candy, nuts
Filling
Flavors: custom (write in your request) Best Sellers: vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, citrus, cream cheese, cookies and cream, black cocoa, spice
Seasonal: salted caramel, spice, dark cocoa (black)
Frosting
- Vegan & Gluten-free requests +$20
- Fresh Florals - $15+
- Toppers/custom fondant/elaborate buttercream designs - $20+
Extras
Treats
[By the Dozen]
$25 - chocolate chip, iced oatmeal, sugar, shortbread (pistachio, chocolate, citrus, floral, chai, vanilla bean), triple ginger snickerdoodles, salted caramel snickerdoodles, gingerbread, custom request
$30 - decorated sugar cookies (custom designs), vegan cookies, gluten-free cookies, and keto cookies
Cookies
$20 - 7" pie -
double crust or crumble
$20 half/ $35 full dozen -
poptarts & hand pies
+$15 vegan and gluten-free
Flavors: apple, cherry, pecan, berry, key lime, lemon, cranberry, chocolate, pumpkin, banana cream
$30 - 6" cheesecake or 8" fruit tart
$30 half/$55 full dozen -
3" rainbow fruit tarts
$30 - 1 dozen cinnamon rolls
Pies +
Size
Local Pick-up and Delivery Options Available
No Shipping
See Calendar for events & availability!
Please plan for a minimum of 5 days and a maximum of 30 days in advance before desired order date!